Sign up for Updates
and the e-Edition
image image

Women's groups, lawmakers say MMA promotes a culture of violence

By Jessica String
Staff writer

Lawmakers and women’s advocacy groups are lobbying against a bill that would allow professional Mixed Martial Arts fighting events in New York state. Following cases of tweets and jokes by fighters about sexual assault, the lack of disciplinary action that followed, combined with the violent nature of the sport, the groups believe bringing the fights to New York will condone violent behavior. Photo by AP.
April 29, 2013
Lawmakers and women's advocacy groups are lobbying against a bill (A.6506/S.2755) that would allow professional Mixed Martial Arts fighting events in New York state.

Following demeaning tweets and jokes about sexual assault by professional fighters, the lack of disciplinary action that followed, combined with the violent nature of the sport, the groups believe bringing the fights to New York will condone violent behavior.

"Cage fighting has no place in a civilized society," said Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffee, D-Suffern. "Except for those who stand to profit from this barbaric entertainment… it harms the fighters who risk their lives, who are often seriously injured, it harms women who are victimized by glorification of distorted masculinity."

Mixed martial arts fighting is a combat fighting sport, generally taking place in a cage, that combines many different forms of fighting.

The groups who held a press conference in Albany last week say some fighters have been spotlighted for sexist or racist comments via social networks while the Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC), a mixed martial arts organization, was criticized for not disciplining its members.

Among the explicit behavior, including graphic commentary on a woman's sexuality and derogatory language, the groups refer to a video where Quinton "Rampage" Jackson jokingly pretends to attempt to rape a woman with Chloroform and zip ties.

"They go out there [and think] that it's okay to violate women, it's okay to physical assault women, it's okay to rape women," said Zenaida Mendez, president of the National Organization for Women (NOW) of New York. "Some of them even have videos of how you can 'get a women fast' as they say. So this is a concern to us."

From left, Zenaida Mandez, president of the National organization for Women, Sen. Krueger, Sen. Hoylman and Deborah Tucker, executive director of the National Center on Domestic and Sexual Violence oppose the bill that would allow professional mixed martial arts fighting in the state because of past incidents of fighter conduct and the violent nature of the sport. Photo by Tanique Williams.
The groups fear the violent sport and demeaning behavior indicates a culture that condones assault and oppression of women.

"The essential damage to people in the community being influenced to believe that violence against women is acceptable and actually used by people who they are coming to admire," said Deborah Tucker, executive director of the National Center on Domestic and Sexual Violence.

"The influence particularly on young men is something we are concerned about. We do not want to see any messages to young boys and young men that encourage sexual assault or violence," Tucker said.

A spokesman for the UFC in New York said the league is addressing these concerns and also notes every sport is forced to deal with misconduct by athletes.

Steven Greenberg, from Greenberg Public Relations, a firm representing the UFC in New York State, said fighters are not the only professional athletes who have been less than a role model.

"There is a minority of MMA fighters who do unfortunate things," said Greenberg, referring to offensive tweets and videos by fighters. "There are also football players, Hollywood entertainers… that's our society."

The UFC has released a "Fighters Conduct Policy" this month, which states that, among other illegal and damaging behavior, disciplinary actions may be imposed by using "derogatory or offensive conduct, including without limitation insulting language symbols, or actions about a person's gender." However, it is up to the UFC to impose investigations and disciplinary actions, which can be "… fines, suspension, and cessation of service."

Lawmakers who oppose lifting the ban on mixed martial arts fighting in New York say it is an inhumane practice and was banned in the first place for this reason. In 1997, the state banned professional MMA sports because they "considered it barbaric and were concerned that children would be desensitized by such extreme violence," according to Jaffee.

"Most martial arts have nothing to do with violence but rather self defense," said Sen. Liz Krueger, D-Manhattan. "But when you get into the commercial mixed martial arts cage fighting… it's very clear that that sport has a different message ... It follows none of the rules of what are recognized as good sportsman like behavior … it's almost a model of supported, free for all violence."

Greenberg said that mixed martial arts is not the only sport that uses such tactics to win a competition and that professional MMA fighting, as opposed to amateur fighting, has rules that give the sport meaning beyond just violence.

"The purpose of MMA is not to get your opponent," said Greenberg. "It is one of the most highly skilled sports; it takes karate, jiu jistu, boxing..." to be successful.

But Krueger believes that despite the violence and player misconduct in other sports, mixed martial arts is crossing a line.

"I do think it's reasonable to say that there is a continuum; that there is obviously aggressive competition in many American sports," Krueger said. "I think what we are saying here is that there are lines that should be drawn by legislative bodies about when too far is too far."

Some lawmakers are pushing to allow professional mixed martial arts fighting, hoping it will help the upstate economically by creating jobs and bringing tourism. But Jaffee and Sen. Brad Hoylman say the economic benefits are overstated and believe it is counterproductive to a progressive state.

"This is somehow going to bring tens of millions of dollars to the state?" asked Hoylman, D-Greenwich Village. "To me that is a pathetic and desperate attempt to salvage a sport that a lot of people know should not be sanctioned professionally."

Krueger said she has proposed a two year moratorium on mixed martial arts that would allow studies to investigate the long term health and psychological effects on fighters, to which Jaffee plans introduce in the assembly as well.

"We have some studies done in …other counties documenting the physical harm that takes place during the fights," said Krueger. "But we haven't had any longitudinal studies of the long term impact of being choke-held and beat at this level of professional sports."

Krueger noted that studies now show many negative long term impacts of professional boxers years after they retired. Hoylman also plans to purpose legislature that will create a health and wellbeing fund for the fighters, in case the MMA bill does pass.

"What the fighters don't have are basic protections," said Hoylman. "Long term health guarantees, an ability to organize-what I could consider-the essence of a civilized and decent workplace; which is being able to bare the risks of such a dangerous sport."

Hoylman said it is only fair that promoters would be the contributors to the fund.

A bill allowing mixed martial arts in New York passed the Senate and was referred to the Assembly Committee on Tourism, Parks, Arts and Sports Development this month.

  1. print email
    April 30, 2013 | 07:16 PM

    I find this article, as well as similar articles, very hippicritical as they deem the sport as too violent, yet they clearly don't refer to any example of which fights are too barbaric, the people who argue against the sport have no relation to the sport, but rather from groups who are more protesting for their own cause (such as the unions from Las Vegas acting against the sport simply because two of the biggest promoters of it owning non-unionised casinos, which should not be given the time of day considering the fact that, if the promoters do unionise their casinos, may stop their protests, even speak highly of it if they do get their way) than truely speaking out against MMA, and also that there really is no real reason to keep it banned.

    In the end of the day, MMA is very much available in the state of New York, such as MMA gyms, advertisements across the cities, shops selling MMA related products (ranging from clothing, to DVDs and video games and training equipment) the amateur MMA scene (which is legal but unregulated, which is far more dangerous for the state to leave it as than keeping pro MMA banned), footage being available in NY showing fights and live events on multiple TV stations, the internet and the Xbox, and even neighbouring states, such as New Jersey, legalise professional MMA for New Yorkers to simply travel to these states to go watch the big events in person, yet for some reason by preventing professional MMA from happening in NY, they somehow prevent MMA from entering the state all together? It makes absolutely no sense to keep it banned if it is available in nearly every other form in the state anyway. If they truely believe that MMA is as evil as they proclaim then the protesters should be lobbying for an all round ban of the sport, like shutting down the shops and gyms, prevent MMA advertising in the state, get rid of the amateur scene, ban it off their state's TV and internet and even go as far as prevent fans from leaving the state around the time of a major event in a nearby state, but they won't because its already a lost fight and they know it.

    They are simply delaying it because these have too much time on their hands and are the sort of people who simply cannot live without anything to complain about. The reality is that they have nothing against the sport itself, they just like to point out its flaws and because of the sport's past they feel they can amplify it in order to either get 15 minutes of fame or to get their cause out there, such as the union groups, but the fact the are targeting something unrelated to them or their causes is rather sad and I urge these people to go find a different, less controversial approach to having their voices heard and to get their own way. After all, if the UFC new Conduct Policies actually work in stopping fighters from tweeting messages that may discriminate certain people or videos that may offend someone, will these womens groups, anti homophobic groups etc drop their statement to stop the sports growth and just simply leave it alone? Answer - yes! Or what if UFC owners unionise their casinos, meaning the unionists have won the fight for their cause, will they take a step back and allow the sport to do its own thing rather than get involved purely to get what they want? Answer - Hell Yes! And because this we should ignore the nay-sayers and come to accept that the sport is ready for its big day in the Empire state. After all what is wrong with the sport today exactly? Go watch K-1 kickboxing bouts on Youtube and see how bloody those fights can get, or go watch a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu tournament to see what exactly they do, then you will see what the sport of mixed martial arts really is about.

    carl gale
  2. print email
    Martial Arts
    July 26, 2013 | 11:53 PM

    Those who oppose Martial Arts apparently want their daughters to grow up to be victims. I lived in South Florida, and the racial climate there was antagonistic to say the least. My 5-year-old daughter came home from her first day at school ans said the boys pulled up her dress and tried to put her hands down her pants. I took her to a judo studio and told them--"teach her how to kill." All throughout jr high and huigh school there were such things as "Cracker Day" and, "Rape Friday." She was one of the few girls who they learned they could not victimize, as she had a black belt in Tae Kwon do by that time. Perhaps you are willing to have your daughter turn up as a statistic someday, or be accused of "racism" because she charged some black of raping her, but I preferred that she was able to defend herself. As Frost said, "Good fences make good neighbors." That goes for white guys too. Men who are pigs come in all colors.

    Chylene Ramsey
  3. print email
    January 09, 2014 | 09:36 PM

    A good portion of the world still enjoys their primitive side. We are no different than apes in the wild watching the two male apes fight for dominance. The audiences for these activities may not realize it be when they watch these fights and enjoy watching them, they are regressing to their primitive side.

    We will always think of our selves as being superior because of brains, but what use is the brain if we can not use it to control our old primitive ways.

Reader Feedback Submission
Use this form to submit Reader Feedback. Your submission will be reviewed by our staff before appearing on the Web site.
* required value
Your Name*



inclusion image
12 - 01 - 15
Site Search

Queens College
Empire State College
NY Ship
The Legislative Gazette | P.O. Box 7329 | Room 116 | Empire State Plaza | Concourse Level | Albany, NY 12224 | (518) 473-9739