Sign up for Updates
and the e-Edition
image image

Medical marijuana bill said to have Senate support

Assemblyman Richard Gottfried, chair of the Assembly Health Committee, speaks at an event detailing the changes to a medical marijuana bill with Sen. Diane Savino. The bill passed the Health committee 21-4. Photo by Jess String.
April 22, 2013
A medical marijuana bill (A.6357/S.4406) drafted to help patients with a debilitating or life-threatening

illness was reported from the Assembly Health Committee last week by a 21-4 vote and Sen. Diane Savino, D-Staten Island, is optimistic this bill will pass the Senate this session.

"Everyone knows this bill has passed the New York State Assembly more than once and everyone knows this bill will likely pass the New York State Assembly fairly easily again. The Senate has always been the stumbling block," Savino said.

She said after lobbying and language changes to the bill, the sponsors gained wider support in the Senate.

Patient Beverly McClain, asked legislators to approve the bill. Photo by Jess String.
Savino specifically noted Sen. John DeFrancisco, R-Syracuse, who previously opposed this bill, has now come around to support it. "We are picking up support member by member."

"My count is 38 solid yes votes, six leaning yes. We only need 32 in the Senate. We're going to get this bill done this year," Savino said, referring to new support in the Senate.

Savino also addressed the opposition to the bill by Gov. Andrew Cuomo, "He said that he has concerns … he is entitled to air those concerns and he will be part of this discussion and in fact he may find that some of his concerns will be addressed in this new piece of legislation."

When Cuomo was asked at a press conference last week whether he would support medical marijuana, he responded, "I do not support medical marijuana. I understand the pros and cons, I understand the argument. We are looking at it, but at this point, I do not support medical marijuana."

Assembly Health Committee Chair Richard Gottfried, D-Manhattan, outlined some of the key changes made to the bill between last session and now. In regards to the definition of a severe debilitating and life-threatening condition, the health commissioner, who would be supported by a clinical advisory that he or she appoints, would be authorized to define debilitating and life-threatening illness in anyway the commissioner sees fit.

"There is a lot more language in the bill authorizing a variety of other pieces of regulation governing the monitoring, including visual monitoring and the tracing of the plant from seed to sale. The regulatory language in the bill is a lot more explicit and involved than it has been in the past." Gottfried said. "There is a tax provision in the bill that would be applied to both manufacturing and dispensing … and the bill provides that half the revenue from that will go to local government."

Savino and Gottfried were joined by supporters of the bill, including members of the New York State Nurses Association; the Pharmacists Society of the State of New York; the Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union; and the New York State AIDS Advisory Council.

"If the patient and physician agree that the patient's severe debilitating or life-threatening condition should be treated with medical marijuana, the government should not stand in the way," Gottfried said. "It is cruel to deny treatment to patients who are suffering or to turn them into criminals."

Patient advocates offered an emotional plea for "compassionate care," to help with their debilitating illnesses including multiple sclerosis and stage-four cancer.

"I am now in stage four, this means I cannot be cured … we just do not understand why anyone would want to take something away from us that helps us, that makes us feel better — we do not have a lot of time," said patient Beverly McClain. "Why can't we have the best possible lives that we are going to get out of that tiny little bit of time we have left? There is really no reason."

Savino and Gottfried denied any linkage between this bill and the recent discussions about decriminalizing small amounts of marijuana to reduce stop-and-frisks in New York City. However, Gottfried noted if you support decriminalizing small amounts of marijuana, it is hard to understand why you would not support medical marijuana.

"I have always felt very strongly that the medical use of marijuana should be kept completely separate from discussions of the recreational use," he said.

"It is hard to explain why, on the one hand, you would be for reducing the penalties for the people who are possessing for recreational use, and I agree with doing that, but why, if you support that, would you continue to stand in the way of people who are really suffering and who are desperate to be able to be allowed to use to ease their suffering?" Gottfried said. "I think it is hard for me to see why you would be for one and not the other."

Savino added, "The discussion about whether we decriminalize small amounts of marijuana in public view is a public policy issue that should be debated and should be discussed, it is about appropriateness of penalty. However; it has nothing to do whatsoever with this particular issue…we are proposing an incredibly tightly regulated process in allowing access to marijuana for people who have determined to have life -threatening debilitating conditions. We are not looking to make it easier…this is not about recreational use of marijuana."

  1. print email
    medical Marijuana
    May 03, 2013 | 02:56 PM

    I am a systemic lupus sufferer and I am suffering from sever weight loss due to loss of appetite. I have had life threatening allergic reactions to all medication my doctor had prescribed including two tma/mild strokes. My
    doctor prescribed Marinol and it helped tremendously. But now my insurance will not pay for it and and I am losing weight again 5'3 and 77 lbs. He told me marijuana would greatly hell me but it is illegal. Why does NY deniy this drug to me when it has the benefit of increased appetite for my terminal desease. If if our representatives family member had this would they not want the best for their loved ones?
    So why not legalize medical marijuana for those that suffer and would greatly benefit from this drug.
    Thank you for listening

    Janet Palumbo NY tax payer and resident

    Janet Palumbo
  2. print email
    May 09, 2013 | 06:26 PM

    I have Ulcerative Colitis. I was taking 12 pills a day and still suffering flare-ups every month. I (re)discovered cannabis recreationaly, after leaving the military. The effect on my health has been miraculous. I now use regularly, in the evening before bed, and have cut down to 4 pills a day and I haven't had a flare up in 6 months. My last colonoscopy even showed the imorovement .
    Hiding my use is not difficult. Old white guys don't get profiled. But the idea that I might get jail time for using a drug that helps me more than any other ever has, is preposterous.
    I have kept my job. It hasn't hurt my relationship with my wife or my family and friends. I have no compulsion to try harder drugs. I use small amounts and never get "wasted". Cannabis has given me the freedom to live my life with less pain and discomfort. Isn't that what drugs are for?

    Andrew D
  3. print email
    Medical Marijuana
    May 27, 2013 | 09:22 PM

    I suffer from knee pains in which medication is not helping me at all. I did use medication but the more I use it the body gets use to it then is not going to work any more so the doctor have to give me something stronger to relive the pains. Look I'm not looking forward to die due to liver or kidney because of the medication that not really working. Is hard to live with pains and our government needs to approve medical marijuana . Please support us remember you are the voice of the people and we the people need to be protected .

Reader Feedback Submission
Use this form to submit Reader Feedback. Your submission will be reviewed by our staff before appearing on the Web site.
* required value
Your Name*



inclusion image
11 - 29 - 15
Site Search

Queens College
Empire State College
NY Ship
The Legislative Gazette | P.O. Box 7329 | Room 116 | Empire State Plaza | Concourse Level | Albany, NY 12224 | (518) 473-9739